HOME      FICTION      NONFICTION      BLOG      DOWNLOADS

Donate      Submit      About       Log In

D.F. McCourt
SFContario 2010 Print

As I’ve mentioned on Twitter, I was at the inaugural SFContario last weekend. There were some excellent panels on Saturday. First thing in the morning, I took in the “Is Extinction Really Forever?” talk with Peter Watts, where an interesting question was raised about the identity of species: What difference between Heck Cattle and Aurochs?


Tea time was held at the Tor.com kaffeeklatsch with the Neilsen Haydens, who regaled us with fantastical stories of life in the Flatiron Building. As a brief aside, there were a few years where I worked as a bicycle messenger in Toronto. As a result, I am intimately familiar with most of the significant buildings in the city, including the grand old ones like Victoria College and 299 Queen West and Old City Hall. I have ridden in some ancient and terrifying elevators in my day, but my conception of “terrifying elevator” underwent a substantial reevaluation after listening to PNH and TNH talk about the Flatiron Building.

Later in the afternoon, I attended another panel that Peter Watts was on. This time the topic was “Biotech: Friend or Foe.” The conversation was riveting, but perhaps the most remarkable thing was the inability of the panelists to come up with a good working definition of biotech. I don’t think this speaks to any failing on their part, but it does raise the question of whether the category of “biotech” is even one worth talking about. Do penicillin and human cloning really have anything meaningful in common? Worth noting is that the nearest definition people could agree upon was ultimately rejected because it failed to exclude the first ox to pull a plough from being an instance of biotech. It seems that all conversations with Peter Watts naturally turn to ancient bovids, given enough time.

And then, in the evening, there was the session I was most looking forward to, entitled simply “Canadian Science Fiction.” Sadly, the panel had a few substantial problems that aren’t worth dwelling on but did cause the conversation to flounder for quite a long time. Fortunately, Robert J. Sawyer was there to steer it back on track. One thing that Rob seems to be quite good at is tossing out quotable quips. Perhaps the best was: “American science fiction has happy endings, Canadian science fiction has sad endings, and British science fiction has no endings at all.”

In all, it was a fantastic time. It seemed to be a very competently run conference, particularly for a first effort. I look forward already to attending in 2011.

 

Comments  

 
# Shay D. 2010-11-25 18:39
I completely forgot to look for you on Saturday. Ironically, we were at two of the same panels (Biotech (although I was a bit late) & Can SF).

As I recall, the quote you mentioned of Rob Sawyer's was actually him quoting someone else, but I didn't catch the attribution.

I did manage to meet one of other AE Micro authors, though, which was fun.
Reply
 
 
# D.F. McCourt 2010-11-25 21:45
As I remember it, Rob said that he was pretty sure someone else (I forget who as well) had said something similar but that that person now denies ever having done so. So Rob changed the phrasing slightly and took it for his own.

Also, it's a shame you didn't say hi. But there will be other opportunities.
Reply
 
 
# RB Rumble 2010-11-26 16:30
I was at that panel too, and if we're thinking of the same "substantial problem" at the Canadian SF panel I wonder why this person was deemed qualified to sit at the table. If his only claim to authority is that he's a long-time SF fan, then any warm body in the audience would have had a similar claim. I found it almost embarrassing that someone that has never written a single published word would consider themselves qualified to tell authors about their craft.
Reply
 

Add comment

Please be polite and respectful of the authors and your fellow commenters. Profanity, used sparingly, will be tolerated; abusive behaviour will not. HTML comments and avatar images are reserved for subscribers. To subscribe, click here.


[log in]

Security code
Refresh

RECENT COMMENTS

AE thanks SF Canada

Banner

SPONSORS

Banner

Twitter

ISSN: 1925-3141